Jonathan Swift Contrast

Thesis statement In the sarcasm A Modest Proposal, Jonathan agile addresses a problem that is extremely heartrending on a grand scale and uses a somber nuance to rescue his solvent however, in the parody An Innocent Proposal, Benjamen Pewitt refers to a less portentous tinge and his plan to fix it is meant to be hilarious. I. Problem A. Swift B. Pewitt II. settlement A. Swift B. Pewitt Most heap have watched and probably laughed at the tv set series South pose or the movie Spaceb alls. These are ii great examples of satire and a parody.Satires and parodies are created in all kinds of formats from movies and video shows to music, books, and plays. One of their main purposes is to entertain the interview, and most of the time they are extremely humorous. But they are also created for very specific reasons. For example, the Merriam-Webster online dictionary defines satire as a literary earn holding up adult male vices and follies to ridicule or scorn. An example is in an episode of South Park when Stans girlfriend breaks up with him because his Facebook status is single. This makes fun of Americas obsession with Facebook.As further noned by Merriam-Webster a parody is A literary or musical work in which the style of the pen or work is closely imitated for comic effect or in ridicule. Spaceballs is a great representation of this definition because it mocks Star Wars, and the absolute mend for the movie is based on Star Wars. In the satire A Modest Proposal Jonathan Swift addresses a problem that is extremely serious on a grand scale and uses a somber stair to present his solution however, in the parody An Innocent Proposal Benjamen Pewitt refers to a less significant reside, and his plan to fix it is meant to be hilarious.Swifts radix country, Ireland, is in a dire state of need, and they are becoming desperate. concourses lives are at s engineer if significant obstacles are not briefly overcome. Jane E. Aaron, the author of the textbook 40 Model Essays, best summarizes the place by writing, Several years of crop failures had resulted in widespread starvation among the Irish poor, yet the government of Englandand the well-to-do Irish had done zip to facilitate (356). This reveals the causes of this disaster. Swift illustrates the severity of the problem when he states, It is a sorrow object to . . count the streets, roads, and cabin doors, crowded with beggars of the female sex, fol small-scaleed by three, four, or six children, all in rags and importuning every passenger for an alms (357). This really paints a picture of how disgusting the streets of Ireland are becoming. Swift talks about how this is ruining the future of Ireland when he says these poor children of Ireland grow up, and they either turn thieves for inadequacy of work, or leave their dear native country to fight for the skulker in Spain, or sell themselves to the Barbados (357).Therefore, if this tragedy in Ireland is not soon fixed, then t he Irish society may collapse. In contrast, Pewitt writes about a minor problem occurring in racy schools everywhere, which is the open display of bosom. In a truly accurate assessment, Pewitt points out, It is definitely a disgusting destiny to see a person pinned to the wall and has become a amazement to both the participant and the innocent passerby (45). It is indeed highly wicked to watch this happen, but nowhere near as hurtful to see women and children stealing and begging for food in the streets of Ireland. Public display of devotion is just one of many small disciplinary hurdles for high schools to overcome, on the other hand the obstacle in Ireland is the main concern for the future of the entire country. Another statement that demonstrates the level of difference surrounded by the two problems is when Pewitt opens his essay by insisting High school administrators, fight now and save many minutes of valuable time and write out your stress level tremendously (45). Pewitt is concerned with teachers drop out time and stress level, however Swift is trying to save the entire country of Ireland from widespread starvation.Although public display of affection is not a very pleasant sight to see and is a growing concern in High Schools, it is not nearly a disaster to the selfsame(prenominal) magnitude as a collapsing society. The solution given by Swift in his essay is intended to be taken very seriously. til now though it is not realistic, he uses a very somber facial expression as he reveals it. His proposal is for his country to actually use the babies in rags that are burdens on their mothers to contribute to the feeding, and partly to the clothing, of many thousands. This way the mothers depart have fewer expenses to worry about, and they can actually make limited money by selling their babies for lots of value if they are by rights fed for nutritional purposes. Also the whole country would benefit because these babies would help feed m any more people since crops are not producing enough. He presents this outrageous claim in such a serious elan in order to give peoples attention, and to show them how urgently they need an answer. He implies they might as well start kill babies if any type of effort is not put forth to help, other than people are going to keep dying anyway if aught else is done.His somber tone is crucial in his attempt to make the audience aware of the intensity of this tragedy and convince them that action needs to take place soon. On the contrary, the plan asserted by Pewitt seems meaningless hence is intended more for entertainment. There is no real threat the public display of affection really poses, and it is something that will continue to happen in future no matter what is done. In other words, Pewitt is mocking the work of Swift, and is simply trying to get a good laugh from his audience.His solution to the public display of affection is an easily accessible fornication grotto. He exp lains the grotto will include soft beds and couches, and some very low Barry White music to set the mood(45) and even a captain advisor to help coach. This shows how sarcastic Pewitt really gets in the humorous tone he uses. In summary, Swift is genuinely trying to fix a problem which may produce severe consequences by suggesting a loaded solution to get peoples attention, and Pewitt parodies his work by sarcastically suggesting the most hilarious plan imaginable.Swift and Pewitt use two totally unalike approaches to answering two totally different problems, and they do this for two solely different reasons. Swift attempts to save the country of Ireland with the use of satire. He writes in a somber tone and offers his unrealistic plan of eating babies to get peoples attention and open their eyes to how dire the military position is becoming. This outrageous idea Swift has came up with serves as ridicule toward the Irish people for not taking any action.He is telling them if the y are not going to think of something they might as well resort to his plan, because people are dying anyway. Pewitt, on the other hand, presents his fornication grotto as a sarcastically ridiculous answer for public display of affection as a parody to the work of Swift. Although, his concern is meaningless in contrast to Swifts, and this is why his tone is not to be taken seriously. Swifts satire was written for an extremely important cause, and all Pewitt wants in his parody is a good laugh.